Chapter 08 · A cited history

History, Hustlers & the Gambling Culture

How the money game shaped one pocket and bank pool — the word, the room, the hustle, Johnston City, and the Derby — told from the record, with the legends marked as legends.

The game is named for the bet.


The money under the table

One pocket and bank pool were not designed in a rules committee. They grew up in rooms where the game was the excuse and the bet was the point, and they still carry that history in how they are played: slow, defensive, easy to handicap, and hard to luck into. This chapter is that history, told from the record.

Pool's gambling past is mostly handed down as stories, and pool hustlers, as the historian R. A. Dyer puts it, “are, by nature, liars” 26. So every claim below carries the kind of evidence behind it: a court opinion or contemporary report record, academic work scholarly, a reference work that cites its own sources reference, later journalism or history secondary, a participant's own account first-person, or oral tradition anecdotal. What could not be traced at all is marked unverified and collected in Flagged.

One more rule: this is not a celebration of the hustle. A hustle is a deception practiced on a person who thinks they are in a fair game. The chapter describes how it worked because the games we play today were shaped by it, not because it is a model.

“Pool” means the pot

The game is named for the bet. In its billiards sense, “pool” is a game played for a collective stake — a pot every player pays into and the winner takes.

Etymonline traces the word to the French poule, “stakes, booty, plunder,” and dates the game sense to 1808 reference1. The Oxford English Dictionary, as Wikipedia summarizes it, is more cautious: the etymology is uncertain, the link runs through games played for collective stakes, and the oldest billiards-like use it records is in a Virginia newspaper in 1797 reference2. The two dates disagree; the meaning does not.

The same word named a second kind of room. Through the late nineteenth century a “poolroom” was also an off-track betting parlor where wagers on horse races were pooled. Steven Riess's history of New York racing gives a full chapter to “The Poolroom Business in Metropolitan New York, 1863–98,” and describes the tracks as the hinge that let “illegal poolrooms and off-course bookies” operate under political protection scholarly3.

A story to doubt

A popular account says betting poolrooms installed billiard tables to keep bettors busy between races, and that the game took its name from the room. No source behind it was found, and the dictionaries tie the word to the stake, not the room unverified F1.

Aimed at the place, not the game

By the early twentieth century the law had decided what a poolroom was before anyone walked in. The game was legal; the room was presumed to be trouble.

North Dakota in 1905 barred anyone under eighteen from playing in, or even visiting, pool, billiard, and card “resorts.” In 1910 Fargo's council proposed closing the halls at eleven at night and banning minors, on the theory that it “would force young men to bed at the proper hour” secondary4.

In 1912 the Supreme Court put the presumption into constitutional law. South Pasadena had banned billiard and pool tables kept for hire, except in hotels with twenty-five or more bedrooms serving registered guests. J. L. Murphy, convicted under the ordinance, offered to prove his hall was orderly and free of gambling. The Court held that he did not get to try record5:

“That the keeping of a billiard hall has a harmful tendency is a fact requiring no proof.… The ordinance is not aimed at the game, but at the place.”Murphy v. California, 225 U.S. 623 (1912)

That is the frame the rest of this chapter lives inside. The ordinance's own exception says it: billiards for a hotel's registered guests was fine, and the public room was the thing to be regulated synthesis. A linguist writing in 1980 described pool rooms as becoming “increasingly the haunts of the down-and-out, chronic gamblers, and other social outcasts” scholarly6.

The rooms also shrank. A figure repeated everywhere, including JSTOR Daily, has American pool halls falling from about 40,000 to 8,000 between 1929 and 1939 6. It is plausible and widely cited, but no primary count behind it was found unverified F2.

The vocabulary of action

A money game is a negotiation before it is a match. Who backs whom, who gives weight, how much is on each game: the words for those things are the trade's working vocabulary.

Hustling
“The deceptive act of disguising one's skill in a sport or game.” reference7
Stakehorse
The backer: “a person who provides the money for the hustler to bet with,” in exchange for a large share of the winnings, and sometimes a hand in the hustle itself reference7.
Sandbagging
Also “dumping”: losing small games on purpose to set up a larger bet against a player who now thinks they are the better one reference7.
Weight / the spot
The handicap that makes a lopsided match bettable: a ball in one pocket, a game on the wire, the 7 as a second money ball in 9-ball. The definitions come from player glossaries anecdotal8; the practice is on the record — Ronnie Allen's trademark weight was playing one-handed against an opponent's two reference17.

The documented techniques of the hustle are all variations on hiding information: losing the small games, missing the easy shots while making the hard ones so early wins look like luck, feigning drink or incompetence until the stakes are right reference7. The weight is the honest half of the same economy. A good player who cannot find an even game has to give something away to get one.

The academic field study of the trade is Ned Polsky's Hustlers, Beats, and Others (1967). Polsky, a sociologist and a skilled three-cushion player 34, wrote chapters on poolrooms and on “the hustler,” treating hustling as an occupation with its own career — recruitment, working life, retirement — rather than as a character type scholarly9. It is the place to start for anyone who wants the trade described from the inside by someone trained to describe it.

One pocket and banks

The two games this chapter is about share a design: each makes luck expensive. In one pocket you score only in your own corner, so a lucky ball in the wrong pocket helps the opponent. In bank pool every scoring shot must come off a rail, so nothing slops in. That is exactly what a player betting on skill wants synthesis.

One pocket

Grady Mathews, one of the game's best-known players and teachers, wrote in 1991 that one pocket “began in Oklahoma in the 30's, if I'm not mistaken” — and that “pool hustlers preferred One Pocket” because luck plays a smaller part than in 9-ball. His measure of the stakes: one pocket players “have played for more money by the game than 9-ball players have by the session” first-person10.

Who invented it is not known. Hayden Lingo of Oklahoma City (1907–1973) is “often cited” as the inventor, on the strength of a Hall of Fame entry; his pamphlet How to Play One Pocket in Pocket Billiards (1963) is in the Library of Congress, and his rules are reported as the basis for the first tournament reference1113. Minnesota Fats's autobiography and Eddie Robin's Winning One Pocket name a “Jack Hill” instead, and no record has either man claiming the invention secondary12 unverified F3.

The establishment's view was blunt. Willie Mosconi, the straight-pool champion, called one pocket “a gimmick game for gamblers” reference13.

Bank pool

Bank pool is listed as first played in the 1930s. For most of its history it was a fifteen-ball game; the shorter nine-ball version gained popularity in the 1990s and 2000s reference14. Its money history is best told by a player the Billiard Congress of America counts among the greatest at it. Eddie Taylor, “the Knoxville Bear” (1918–2005), took up banks because that was where the action was first-person15:

“All over the South, all the big money games were all bank pool.… Of course, the big money back then was like $5 a game.”Eddie Taylor, Billiards Digest interview, 2003

He named Kentucky, Tennessee, Alabama, and Georgia. A theory that bank pool caught on because rooms charged by the rack and banks are slow is forum speculation only unverified F4.

The hustlers' tournament, 1961–1972

For eleven years the money game had a home with a scoreboard. Two brothers in a southern Illinois town ran a tournament for the players and the games the sanctioning bodies left out, and the action around it was the point.

One pocket, fourteen players

The first event opened on October 25, 1961, at George and Paulie Jansco's Show Bar in Johnston City, Illinois1016. Fourteen players entered secondary16. It was a tournament for a game the Billiard Congress of America did not recognize, played by known hustlers who had not entered sanctioned events, promoted by a newcomer whose roots were “more in the gambling side of pool” first-person10. Johnny Vives won 13.

The Hustler had premiered a month earlier, on September 25 21. On December 4, Sports Illustrated ran Tom Fox's feature on the tournament, built around the player then calling himself New York Fats secondary19.

The all-around

Nine-ball and straight pool joined one pocket, and the event became an all-around championship secondary16. Luther “Wimpy” Lassiter — described as the “undisputed king” of the hustlers, who with Don Willis worked rooms across the country — won it in 1962 and 1963 reference20.

Cisero Murphy played in 1963, which Dyer counts among the first integrated national-class tournaments secondary16 unverified F5. The contrast with the establishment is documented: the next year players picketed the Commodore Hotel in Manhattan over Murphy's exclusion from the BRPAA tournament reference22.

The Bear and the champions

Eddie Taylor beat Lassiter in the 1964 all-around final, a year after losing to him there record15. Murphy won the world straight pool title in 1965 on his first attempt 22. Lassiter took the all-around again in 1967 and 1969 20.

The hustlers' tournament had become the place where tournament players and money players met on the same tables — the room the sanctioned game had kept them out of synthesis.

Fast Eddie's game

Ronnie Allen won the 1970 one pocket title. He called himself “a predator and a hustler,” and the weight he offered — one hand against two — became his trademark reference17.

The raid

Federal agents raided the October 1972 tournament, and it was the last secondary18. The archive of Dick Kay's television report that week records that the agents were in the crowd while his crew filmed, waited until the following night, and that “no convictions resulted from the raid” record23. Which agency led it is told several ways unverified F6.

In 2019 the Billiard Congress of America, which had not recognized the first tournament's game, inducted the Jansco brothers into its Hall of Fame for meritorious service record24.

The myth machine

The most famous hustler in American history is a fictional character, and the man who took his name spent the rest of his life trading on the confusion. Fats is the clearest case of why this chapter tags its evidence.

R. A. Dyer, who wrote the two long-form histories of this era — Hustler Days (2003) and The Hustler & the Champ (2007) secondary2728 — puts the problem in one line: “Pool hustlers are, by nature, liars” 26. Pick a claim to see it set against the record.

The claim

Rudolf Wanderone, who played as “New York Fats,” took the name “Minnesota Fats” after the 1961 film and said the character was based on him 26.

The record

Walter Tevis wrote the character for his 1959 novel and denied the claim for the rest of his life: “Come on, I made him up” reference2526. His manuscript shows “New York” struck out for “Minnesota,” more than once 2526.

Verdict. Open. The manuscript shows Tevis considered the name; it does not show he modeled the character on Wanderone.

The claim

America's most famous pool player, with his own television shows from 1967 — Minnesota Fats Hustles the Pros, then Celebrity Billiards 26.

The record

Wanderone “never won a major pool tournament as ‘Fats.’” The Billiard Congress of America inducted him in 1984 for meritorious service — promotion, not titles reference26.

Verdict. Fame, not titles. The Hall of Fame category says so.

The claim

Fats repeatedly said he had beaten Willie Mosconi.

The record

Mosconi sued him for slander over the claims. On February 14, 1978, they played on ABC's Wide World of Sports at the Waldorf-Astoria, with Howard Cosell calling it, and Mosconi won reference26. The audience is given as about 11 million in one account and 20 million in others unverified F7.

Verdict. The televised match is on the record, and Mosconi won it.

Even his death date carries two versions: January 15, 1996, per the record Wikipedia cites, and January 18 in the New York Times obituary and elsewhere unverified F10.

Hollywood sells the hustle, then the industry sells the room

Both of pool's modern booms were started by films about hustlers. The second one ended with the industry working hard to make sure the rooms no longer looked like the films.

1961: The Hustler

Robert Rossen's film, with Paul Newman as Fast Eddie Felson and Jackie Gleason as Minnesota Fats, is credited with “sparking a resurgence in the popularity of pool in the United States, which had been on the decline for decades.” Willie Mosconi was its technical adviser and shot trick shots for the actors; it also made him a name outside the game reference21. A widely repeated figure of 2,000 new rooms within six months has no traceable source unverified F8.

1986: The Color of Money

Two years after the sequel, the Billiard Congress of America's surveys showed equipment sales up “better than 100 percent,” and a Gallup estimate in February 1988 put American pool players at 33 million secondary29. The new rooms were built against the old image. The UPI report quotes the manager of a 21,000-square-foot California room with no liquor and senior rates, and a table maker: “the days of the old pool hall dungeons are past us now” 29. By 1990 upscale rooms were opening in New York, Atlanta, Boston, Dallas, and Seattle secondary30.

The pattern is worth naming. Each film sold the romance of the money game to a public that would never play one; each boom filled rooms with players for whom the hustle was a story synthesis.

Johnston City, with a casino and a camera

The hustlers' tournament came back as a convention. The money games that used to happen in back rooms now happen under lights, and sometimes on a live stream.

Greg Sullivan of Diamond Billiards first went to Johnston City at sixteen. In 1999 he started the Derby City Classic in Louisville, and he describes it as “Johnson City… on steroids” secondary31. (Wikipedia gives 1997 as the start year, though its own list of winners begins in 1999 unverified F9.) The event now runs every January at a casino in Elizabeth, Indiana, and its structure is Johnston City's, formalized reference32:

  • Bank pool, one pocket, and nine-ball, played one after another, with buy-backs.
  • An all-around title, the Master of the Table, for the player who does best across all three.
  • A winner-take-all bank pool ring game founded by Grady Mathews, held since 2004.
  • The One Pocket Hall of Fame's annual gala.
  • An “Action and Entertainment” award named for Louie Roberts, a player known for high-stakes gambling.

The private money match also went public. In January 2010 The Action Report streamed a ten-hour, $10,000 one pocket challenge between Harry Platis and Karl Bailey on its live channel, with some feature matches sold as pay-per-view secondary33. A game that once depended on nobody knowing how good you were is now played for an audience that knows exactly synthesis.

Five things the record supports

Strip out the legends and a shorter, sturdier history is left. Each point names what carries it.

  1. The game is named for the stake

    “Pool” means a game for a collective pot; the dictionaries agree on that much even where they disagree on dates reference12.

  2. The law judged the room, not the game

    The Supreme Court let a city ban public pool rooms without proof that any harm occurred in them record5. That presumption is the background to every story of the back room.

  3. One pocket and banks were money games first

    Their players say so — bank pool was the South's big money game, one pocket the hustlers' choice — and straight pool's great champion called one pocket a gimmick for gamblers first-person101315. Their design punishes luck, which is what a skill bet needs synthesis.

  4. Johnston City made the money players a field

    For eleven years a tournament outside the sanctioning bodies gathered the hustlers, crowned the all-around champions, and ended in a federal raid that produced no convictions record102023. Its format lives on at the Derby City Classic 3132.

  5. The famous stories are the least reliable

    The best-known hustler is a novelist's invention whose name a real player took; his titles, his victories over Mosconi, even his death date come in versions reference2526. Where a pool story is memorable, check it twice.

Every story, named

The registry behind every citation in this chapter, grouped by the kind of evidence it is. The chapter's research document, with each claim and its tag, is in the repository at docs/research/history-hustlers-gambling.md.

Court records, contemporary reports & scholarship

5Murphy v. California, 225 U.S. 623 (1912) — the South Pasadena billiard-hall ban upheld; “harmful tendency… requiring no proof” record
23richsamuels.com — Dick Kay and the Johnston City, Illinois, Pool Hustlers — archive of a 1972 television report: the raid, “no convictions resulted” record
3Steven A. Riess, The Sport of Kings and the Kings of Crime (Syracuse University Press, 2011) — New York's betting poolrooms, 1863–1913, and their political protection scholarly
9Ned Polsky, Hustlers, Beats, and Others (Aldine, 1967) — catalog record — field study of pool hustling as an occupation; chapters on poolrooms and the hustler scholarly
6JSTOR Daily — Katrina Gulliver, “Playing It Straight and Catching a Break” (2024) — quotes Robert R. Craven, American Speech 55:2 (1980); repeats the 40,000 → 8,000 figure scholarly / secondary

Reference works

1Etymonline — “pool” — French poule, “stakes”; game sense by 1808 reference
2Wikipedia — Pool (cue sports) — etymology per the OED; 1797 Virginia newspaper reference
7Wikipedia — Hustling — hustling, the stakehorse, sandbagging reference
11Wikipedia — Hayden W. Lingo — “often cited” inventor; 1963 rules pamphlet at the Library of Congress reference
13Wikipedia — One-pocket — first tournament 1961, Johnny Vives; Mosconi's “gimmick game” reference
14Wikipedia — Bank pool — 1930s; fifteen-ball and nine-ball versions reference
17Wikipedia — Ronnie Allen — 1970 Johnston City one pocket; one-handed weight reference
20Wikipedia — Luther Lassiter — all-around titles 1962, 1963, 1967, 1969; road years reference
21Wikipedia — The Hustler (film) — premiere September 25, 1961; Mosconi as adviser; the resurgence reference
22Wikipedia — Cisero Murphy — the 1964 picket; 1965 world title reference
25Wikipedia — The Hustler (novel) — Tevis: “I made him up”; the manuscript reference
26Wikipedia — Rudolf Wanderone — the name, the record, the 1978 match, the slander suit reference
32Wikipedia — Derby City Classic — format, Master of the Table, ring game, awards reference
34Wikipedia — Ned Polsky — sociologist; three-cushion player reference

Pool history & journalism

4Prairie Public — “The Disreputable Pool Hall” (2024) — North Dakota's 1905 law; Fargo, 1910 secondary
16R. A. Dyer — “Memories of the Famous Johnston City Hustler Jamborees” — the Janscos, the format, the 1963 field secondary
12R. A. Dyer — “One-Pocket Mystery: Who Invented the Hustlers' Game?” — Lingo, Hill, and no claim from either secondary
18R. A. Dyer — “American Pool History: A Timeline” (2015) — the October 26, 1972 raid secondary
19R. A. Dyer — “The Discovery of Johnston City and Minnesota Fats” — Tom Fox's Sports Illustrated feature, December 4, 1961 secondary
27R. A. Dyer, Hustler Days (Lyons Press, 2003) — Fats, Lassiter, Jersey Red secondary
28R. A. Dyer, The Hustler & the Champ (2007) — Mosconi and Fats secondary
29UPI — “Billiard boom shows no sign of decline” (1988) — sales doubled; 33 million players; “dungeons” secondary
31AZBilliards — “A Brief History of the Derby City Classic” (2018) — 1999; “Johnson City… on steroids” secondary
33AZBilliards — “The Heat is on in the TAR Pit” (2010) — the streamed $10,000 one pocket challenge secondary

Players in their own words

10Grady Mathews, “History of One Pocket,” On The Snap (1991), at OnePocket.org — Oklahoma origins; the hustlers' preference; October 25, 1961 first-person
15BCA release — “Knoxville Bear” Eddie Taylor, 1918–2005 — “all the big money games were all bank pool”; the 1964 final first-person / record
8AZBilliards forums — pool slang threads — player glossaries: weight, the spot anecdotal
Failed verification

Flagged: not verified

These claims circulate in pool history but did not survive verification against a traceable source. They are printed where they come up with the unverified tag, and collected here so the gaps are impossible to miss.

  • F1Billiard tables entered betting poolrooms, and the game took the room's name. Found only on a commercial blog; the etymological sources tie the word to the stake.
  • F240,000 American pool halls in 1929, 8,000 in 1939. Widely repeated, including by JSTOR Daily; no primary census or trade count found.
  • F3Who invented one pocket. Lingo, Hill, or neither; no contemporaneous record, and neither man claimed it.
  • F4Bank pool caught on because rooms charged by the rack. Forum speculation only.
  • F5Johnston City 1963 as among the first integrated national-class tournaments. A single secondary source that could not be re-read during research.
  • F6Which agency raided Johnston City in 1972, and whether charges were dropped after Minnesota Fats testified. Accounts name the IRS with state police, or the FBI; the archived report says “federal agents” and “no convictions.”
  • F7The size of the 1978 Mosconi–Fats television audience. About 11 million per Wikipedia's cited source; 20 million in other accounts.
  • F82,000 new pool rooms within six months of The Hustler. No source found.
  • F9The Derby City Classic's first year. 1999 per AZBilliards and its founder; 1997 per Wikipedia, whose own winners list starts in 1999.
  • F10Minnesota Fats's date of death. January 15, 1996, per Wikipedia; January 18 per the New York Times obituary and Dyer's timeline.

About access

poolhistory.com, the most thorough secondary source on Johnston City, could not be reached during the research for this chapter. Claims resting on it (sources 12, 16, and 19) were taken from summaries of its pages and are tagged secondary; they should be re-read against the pages themselves.